Updated: November 13, 2026
What Are Annuity Surrender Charges? (How They Work & How to Avoid Them)
Key Takeaways:
- Surrender Charge Scale: Standard annuity surrender charges typically start at higher percentages (e.g., 7%) in contract year one and decline annually to 0%.
- Surrender Fee Application: Surrender fee percentages typically apply only to withdrawal amounts exceeding a contract's penalty-free allowance.
- Tax Rules (LIFO): Earnings on non-qualified annuities are generally withdrawn and taxed first as ordinary income under IRS Last-In, First-Out rules.
- IRS Early Withdrawal Penalty: Annuity withdrawals prior to age 59½ may incur a 10% IRS tax penalty on taxable earnings.
- 1035 Exchange: Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code allows tax-free transfers between non-qualified annuity contracts.
- Contract Ownership Rights: During the accumulation period, only the contract owner (not the annuitant) holds the legal authority to surrender a deferred annuity contract.
- Market Value Adjustment: Certain annuity contracts also apply a market value adjustment to withdrawals taken during the surrender charge period. This adjustment has the ability to increase or decrease the value of your contract.
An annuity surrender charge is a contractual fee assessed by an insurance company if you withdraw funds beyond your policy's penalty-free allowance or cancel the contract early. Standard surrender charge schedules typically start with a higher percentage that decreases each contract year, eventually becoming zero. When you purchase an annuity for future retirement income, there is always a chance that you will need some of your cash earlier than expected, so it’s important to understand your contract’s surrender charges and how they affect your long-term retirement strategy. To keep your money accessible, Canvas Annuity designs fixed deferred annuities like the Future Fund ($2,500 minimum) with built-in withdrawal flexibility, permitting annual withdrawals of up to 10% of your account value without surrender charges. They also include a waiver of surrender charges rider, free of charge, that allows for penalty free withdrawals if certain health conditions are met.
What Is an Annuity Surrender Charge?
An annuity surrender charge is a fee assessed when you withdraw cash from a deferred annuity before the agreed-upon surrender charge period expires. Insurance carriers enforce this fee to recoup up-front administrative, operational, and distribution expenses incurred when establishing the policy. Understanding these terms is a critical step when learning how annuities work and picking a growth strategy aligned with your timeline.
It is equally important to distinguish surrendering an annuity from selling policy payments. Surrendering an annuity cancels the contract directly with the issuing carrier in exchange for its remaining cash surrender value. Selling an annuity involves transferring your right to future payment streams to a secondary-market buyer while the contract remains in force. Consumer advisories from regulatory authorities like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) encourage buyers to evaluate surrender terms before committing capital.
The Surrender Charge Period
The annuity surrender period represents the specified multi-year timeframe during which surrender penalties apply to excess withdrawals. This period commonly lasts anywhere from 3 to 10 years depending on the selected policy structure. Once this period expires, your funds become fully liquid, permitting surrender-charge-free withdrawals, tax-free rollovers, or annuitization.
How Much Are Surrender Charges, and How Long Do They Last?
Surrender fees typically start at their highest percentage in year one and decrease incrementally each contract year until they reach 0%. The length of the surrender schedule typically matches the duration of your guaranteed rate term.
Below is an example of a standard multi-year surrender schedule pattern across a 7-year surrender period:
|
Contract Year |
Surrender Charge |
|
Year One |
7% |
|
Year Two |
6% |
|
Year Three |
5% |
|
Year Four |
4% |
|
Year Five |
3% |
|
Year Six |
2% |
|
Year Seven |
1% |
|
Year Eight+ |
0% |
For illustration only. Surrender charge schedules vary by contract.
Charges Vary by Annuity Type
Fixed annuities sometimes feature shorter surrender schedules and lower percentage fees than indexed or variable annuities. To compare structures across product categories, explore our guide on the types of annuities.
Ways to Avoid or Reduce Annuity Surrender Charges
Placing your retirement funds in an interest-earning, income-producing annuity does not have to require giving up access to your cash. Modern contracts often offer avenues to access your funds without triggering penalties. Before selecting an annuity, review the early withdrawal rules. If unexpected cash needs arise during your annuity contract, review penalty-free withdrawal allowances can keep your long-term plan intact.
Use the Free Withdrawal Provision
Many fixed deferred annuity contracts include an annual penalty-free withdrawal allowance. Canvas Annuity builds this feature directly into the Future Fund, enabling policyholders to withdraw up to 10% of their total balance each year without incurring a surrender charge. This gives conservative savers consistent liquidity while remaining assets compound on a tax-deferred basis.
Check for a Surrender Charge Waiver
Some annuity contracts incorporate hardship waivers that waive surrender charges when specific life events occur. Common waiver triggers include nursing home confinement, terminal illness, or meeting compulsory required minimum distributions (RMDs) on qualified accounts. The Future Fund includes a waiver of surrender charges rider that allows for a penalty free surrender of the contract in certain situations. Additionally, the Future Fund provides a surrender-charge-free death benefit so your beneficiaries receive the full account value without surrender charges and does not assess surrender charges on RMDs.
Use the Free Look Period
In most states, the free look period for annuities is a window lasting between 10 and 30 days right after purchase. During this period, you can return your policy for a full refund without incurring any surrender fees. However, not every state requires a free look period, so it’s also important to consider whether your annuity contract guarantees a similar window. Canvas Annuity backs every purchase with a full 30-day money-back guarantee, issued by Puritan Life Insurance Company of America.
Consider a 1035 Exchange Instead of Surrendering
If you want to move your capital into a higher-yield policy, executing a 1035 exchange allows you to transfer balances tax-free under IRS regulations. While a 1035 exchange avoids triggering immediate income taxes, it does not erase surrender fees assessed by your existing carrier if you are still within their fee schedule. Always verify your original contract terms before initiating an exchange.
Tax Impact of Surrendering an Annuity
Surrendering a deferred annuity can trigger tax liabilities under IRS guidelines. For non-qualified contracts, the IRS enforces Last-In, First-Out (LIFO) tax rules, meaning earnings are withdrawn and taxed first as ordinary income. Furthermore, taking a surrender payout before reaching age 59½ may incur a 10% IRS early withdrawal penalty on the taxable gains.
Important: Consult a tax or financial professional for advice specific to your situation, as annuity taxation depends on funding source, account type, and personal tax circumstances. The information here is educational only and not tax advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do all annuities have surrender charges?
No. Most fixed deferred annuities have surrender schedules, but immediate annuities like the Forever Fund from Canvas Annuity ($10,000 minimum) begin income payments within 30 to 365 days and generally can’t be surrendered. See our types of annuities overview.
How are surrender charges calculated?
A surrender charge is typically a percentage of the amount withdrawn above your contract's penalty-free allowance. If you withdraw $15,000 from a $100,000 contract with a 10% ($10,000) allowance, the charge applies only to the $5,000 excess. Formulas vary by insurer.
Can I withdraw money from my annuity without paying a surrender charge?
Yes, by staying within your contract's annual penalty-free allowance. The Future Fund from Canvas Annuity allows withdrawals of up to 10% per year without surrender charges. Many contracts also waive charges for required minimum distributions or qualifying events.
Who can surrender a deferred annuity?
Only the contract owner can surrender an annuity. An annuitant who isn’t the owner can’t. Joint owners typically must both sign.
What's the difference between surrendering an annuity and selling it?
Surrendering ends the contract with the insurer in exchange for its cash surrender value. Selling transfers your rights to future payments to a third-party buyer, while the policy stays in force. See our guide on selling annuities.
Whether you need steady growth or guaranteed income, compare the Future Fund and Forever Fund to see which fits your retirement goals.
Resource Hub

